The War of Words Over Obscenity
Table of Contents
Introduction to the question of obscenity’s definition and use
Dive into the precise legal definition of obscenity according to Miller v. California
Discussion of how the term “obscene” is used in imprecise ways to chill speech
Overview of how obscenity has been used to silence marginalized voices (as a subset of broader bans’ inequality)
Transition suggesting the end of the terminological debate is the beginning of the ideological debate
Discussion of some sources on the deeper issue of protecting access to varied ideas, with an emphasis on sources that might appeal across political divides
Quick summation and takeaways
Dr. Pat Lawrence's Reading Recommendations
This brief short course is 13 minutes long. To access each section as a short video clip that can be shared online, please continue scrolling down.
"A War on Words Over Obscenity" Section Videos
Part 1: An introduction to the question of obscenity’s definition and use.
Part 2: The precise legal definition of obscenity according to Miller v. California.
Part 3: How the term “obscene” is used in imprecise ways to chill speech.
Part 4: How the term "obscenity" has been used to silence marginalized voices.
Part 5: From terms to ideas and connecting across the political divide.
Reading Recommendations
Perversion for Profit: The Politics of Pornography and the Rise of the New Right, Whitney Strub, Columbia University Press 2013
Obscene Gestures: Counter-Narratives of Sex and Race in the Twentieth Century, Patrick S. Lawrence, Fordham University Press 2022
Reading the Obscene: Transgressive Editors and the Class Politics of US Literature, Jordan S. Carroll, Stanford University Press 2021
The Novel and the Obscene: Sexual Subjects in American Modernism, Florence Dore, Stanford University Press, 2005
Unclean Lips: Obscenity, Jews, and American Culture, Josh Lambert, NYU Press, 2013
The End of Obscenity: The Trials of Lady Chatterley, Tropic of Cancer, and Fanny Hill, Random House, Charles Rembar 1968 (This is an older, popular book, but for people interested in legal history, it provides a lot of wonky detail to sink your teeth into.)
Obscenity and the Limits of Liberalism: Edited by Loren Glass and Charles Francis Williams, Ohio State University Press 2011
Book Banning in 21st-Century America, Emily J. M. Knox, Rowman and Littlefield 2015
Shortcourse Designed by Patrick Lawrence, Ph. D.
Patrick S. Lawrence is an Associate Professor of English at the University of South Carolina, Lancaster. His research focuses on censorship controversies and American political and social movements. He is currently co-editing a collection of essays about obscenity discourses and comics history called Out of the Gutters: Obscenity, Censorship, and Transgression in American Comics (under advance contract with University of Texas Press). His book Obscene Gestures: Counter-Narratives of Sex and Race in the Twentieth Century (Fordham 2022) reconsiders the divergent afterlives of twentieth-century texts that depict taboo subjects based on different narratives of racial, sexual, and gendered possibility. His research appears or is forthcoming in American Literature, Mosaic, Asian American Literature: Discourses and Pedagogies, and Intertexts and in collections from Cambridge University Press, University Press of Mississippi, and Utah University Press.